I found some more stuff, although I don't remember why I liked them:

GOING OUT
Supper Club
Chateau de la Romanee
Conti
St Georges Road, North Fitzroy

EATING
Hot Chocolate, Pavilion 1, Waterfront City
Smith St

SHOPPING
Johnson St - Alexandra Parade, Fitzroy
Flinders Quarter (precinct in and around Flinders Lane, Degraves St and Centre Pl)